November 18, 2026

Extending time for service

In deciding whether to grant a motion to extend the time for service in the interest of justice, the court must carefully analyze the factual setting of the case and a balancing of the competing interests presented by the parties. Unlike an extension request premised on good cause, a plaintiff need not establish reasonably diligent efforts at service as a threshold matter. However, the court may consider diligence, or the lack thereof, along with any other relevant factor in making its determination, including expiration of the statute of limitations, the meritorious nature of the cause of action, the length of delay in service, the promptness of a plaintiff's request for the extension of time, and prejudice to defendant. An extension of time for service is a matter within the court's discretion.

Bank of Am., N.A. vs. Cean, NY Slip Op 06677 (2d Dep't November 12, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 17, 2026

Admissibility of expert testimony

The trial court providently exercised its discretion in excluding defendants' proposed biomechanical expert from testifying at trial, as defendants failed to sustain their burden of demonstrating that the expert's methodology - his own injury causation analysis - was generally accepted in the field of biomechanics.

Larrea vs. Sanitation Salvage Corp., NY Slip Op 06575 (1st Dep't November 12, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 16, 2026

Suing a municipality

When a municipality has adopted a prior written notice law, the municipality cannot be held liable for a defect within the scope of the law absent the requisite written notice, unless an exception to the requirement applies. Where such a local law is in effect, prior written notice of a defective condition is a condition precedent to maintaining an action against the municipality. To be entitled to summary judgment, the municipality must first establish that it lacked prior written notice of the alleged defect. Upon that showing, the burden shifts to the plaintiff to demonstrate the applicability of one of two recognized exceptions to the rule: that the municipality affirmatively created the defect through an act of negligence, or that a special use resulted in a special benefit to the locality.

Anderson vs. County of Suffolk, Inc., NY Slip Op 06676 (2d Dep't November 12, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 15, 2026

Res judicata

The doctrine of res judicata operates to preclude the reconsideration of claims actually litigated and resolved in a prior proceeding, as well as claims for different relief against the same party which arise out of the same factual grouping or transaction, and which should have or could have been resolved in the prior proceeding. Under New York's transactional approach to the rule, once a claim is brought to a final conclusion, all other claims arising out of the same transaction or series of transactions are barred, even if based upon different theories or if seeking a different remedy. Collateral estoppel is a narrower species of res judicata. It precludes a party from relitigating in a subsequent action or proceeding an issue clearly raised in a prior action or proceeding and decided against that party or those in privity, whether or not the tribunals or causes of action are the same. The doctrine of collateral estoppel applies when: (1) the issues in both proceedings are identical; (2) the issue in the prior proceeding was actually litigated and decided; (3) there was a full and fair opportunity to litigate in the prior proceeding; and (4) the issue previously litigated was necessary to support a valid and final judgment on the merits. The party seeking the benefit of collateral estoppel bears the burden of proving that the identical issue was necessarily decided in the prior action or proceeding and is decisive of the present action or proceeding. The party against whom preclusion is sought bears the burden of demonstrating the absence of a full and fair opportunity to contest the prior determination.

111 Heitz Pl., Inc. vs. Rodriguez, NY Slip Op 06675 (2d Dep't November 12, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 14, 2026

Appellate practice

The Appellate Division declines to consider plaintiff's argument that defendant's motion to dismiss should have been denied as academic based on its amendment of the complaint. Plaintiff failed to raise the argument after defendant moved against the original complaint, and cannot be heard to complain after it charted its own course by amending it.

Iron Horse Credit, LLC vs. Wilner, NY Slip Op 06573 (1st Dep't November 12, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 13, 2026

Contract law

When parties clearly express their intention that a subsequent agreement supersedes a prior one, the latter agreement controls. Thus, when the subsequent agreement contains an arbitration clause, the clause will apply to disputes predating the agreement that were not subject to arbitration.

Deshmukh vs. Kasowitz Benson Torres, LLP, NY Slip Op 06550 (1st Dep't November 10, 2026)

Here is the decision.

The indemnification claim was properly dismissed because the ndemnification provision is not unmistakably clear in its intention to include attorneys' fees in intra-party disputes. It is not enough that the provision is broad.

Invictus Global Mgt., LLC vs. Corbin Capital Partners, L.P., NY Slip Op 06572 (1st Dep't November 12, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 12, 2026

A time-barred Article 78 petition

At issue is the judgment,  denominated an order, denying the petition to annul a determination of the Columbia University trustees denying petitioner's transfer application, and dismissing the proceeding brough pursuant to CPLR article 78. The petition is time-barred. The August 25, 2025 email from a Columbia University dean to petitioner stating that "admissions decisions are final" and "[t]here is no appeal process" was an unambiguously final decision as to petitioner's transfer application. Petitioner did not commence this proceeding until more than four months later, on December 30, 2025. Even assuming that another university official's earlier email suggested that an appeal was available, the August 25 email unequivocally foreclosed that possibility and put petitioner on notice that the limitations period had commenced. Petitioner did not demonstrate any fraud, misrepresentation, or deception that would justify the application of equitable estoppel.

Matter of Anonymous vs. Trustees of Columbia Univ. in the City of N.Y., NY Slip Op 06549 (1st Dep't November 10, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 10, 2026

Discovery

Supreme Court providently exercised its discretion in denying petitioner's motion for leave to seek disclosure of metadata, pursuant to CPLR 408). Petitioner failed to show unusual circumstances or ample need for the disclosing the metadata, as the documents submitted with the petition and cross-motion to dismiss were sufficient to determine the relevant issue.

Matter of Davis vs. Oddo, NY Slip Op 06522 (1st Dep't November 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 9, 2026

A time-barred defamation claim.

Supreme Court properly granted defendants' motion to dismiss plaintiff's causes of action for defamation because they were barred by the one-year statute of limitations, pursuant to CPLR 215 [3]. The alleged defamatory statements were made in 2019 and plaintiff commenced this action in 2024, well outside the one-year limitations period. That plaintiff did not discover the alleged defamation until 2023 is not relevant because the limitations period begins to run upon publication.

The statute of limitations was not tolled due to equitable estoppel, as plaintiff cannot demonstrate that he reasonably relied on defendants' alleged deceptions and misrepresentations which in turn induced him to refrain from filing a timely action. This is so given plaintiff's separate ongoing litigation against these defendants and others, commenced in 2015, alleging fraud and misrepresentations. Thus, any claim that plaintiff relied on defendants' subsequent representations was not reasonable. Defendants also had no duty to disclose the purportedly offending documents. The 2015 action, which would have otherwise been in discovery, had been dismissed at the time that the statements were made and was not reinstated by this Court until well over a year later. Further, even upon reinstatement, plaintiff served no discovery demands in that action until 2024.

Brigham vs. Arnold, NY Slip Op 06520 (1st Dep't November 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 8, 2026

Appellate practice

Plaintiff was not aggrieved by the court's order to compel, which was decided in her favor, and thus her cross-appeal therefrom is dismissed, pursuant to CPLR 5511. This is so even though she disagrees with the opinion supporting the order below. 

Anil vs. City of New York, NY Slip Op 06519 (1st Dep't November 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 7, 2026

Attorneys' fees

The cause of action for attorneys' fees was properly dismissed because this claim is not recognized in New York as a separate cause of action. They are recoverable only as an element of contract damages.

Ahmed vs Choudhry, NY Slip Op 06518 (1st Dep't November 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 6, 2026

Time to serve

 Pursuant to CPLR 306-b, a plaintiff is required to serve the summons and complaint within 120 days after commencement of the action. If service of the summons and complaint is not made upon the defendant within that time, the court, upon motion, shall dismiss the action without prejudice as to that defendant, or upon good cause shown or in the interest of justice, extend the time for service. To establish good cause, a plaintiff must demonstrate reasonable diligence in attempting service.

If good cause for an extension is not established, the court must consider the broader interest of justice standard of CPLR 306-b. Under the interest of justice standard, the court may consider diligence, or lack thereof, along with any other relevant factor in making its determination, including expiration of the Statute of Limitations, the meritorious nature of the cause of action, the length of delay in service, the promptness of a plaintiff's request for the extension of time, and prejudice to the defendant.

CPLR 308(5) vests a court with discretion to direct an alternative method for service of process when it has determined that the methods set forth in CPLR 308(1), (2), and (4) are impracticable. A plaintiff seeking to effect expedient service must make some showing that the other prescribed methods of service could not be made.

ARCPE 1, LLC vs. Canales, NY Slip Op 06405 (2d Dep't November 4, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 5, 2026

Vacatur

Supreme Court providently denied defendant's motion to vacate the judgment pursuant to CPLR 5015(a)(1), (a)(4) and in the interest of justice. The motion was not made within the one-year time period under CPLR 5015(a)(1). Moreover, defendant failed to provide any explanation for the default or an affidavit of merit as to its defenses. As the proposed answer was verified by an attorney without personal knowledge of the facts, it was insufficient to set forth a meritorious defense. As to CPLR 5015(a)(4), it was undisputed that plaintiff served the Secretary of State, and, thus, the court obtained jurisdiction even if those documents never reached defendant. Finally, defendant was not entitled to vacatur in the interest of justice.

Whitaker vs. 1975-1983 Jerome Ave. Corp., NY Slip Op 06398 (1st Dep't October 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 4, 2026

Appellate practice

Plaintiff's failure to include some relevant documents in the record on appeal does not preclude a meaningful review. Plaintiff's arguments are based largely on prior decisions issued by the motion court. Moreover, the record contains the notice of appeal, the order appealed from, the initial motion for summary judgment and the amended notice of motion, and the documents submitted in support of those motions.

Ann Arbor Group, LLC vs. Gherardi, NY Slip Op 06399 (1st Dep't October 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

Defendant's argument that plaintiff failed to comply with CPLR 3215(g)(4)(i) because a second copy of the summons and complaint were not served by plaintiff at defendant's last known address is improperly raised for the first time on appeal, and the Appellate Division declines to review it.

Whitaker vs. 1975-1983 Jerome Ave. Corp., NY Slip Op 06398 (1st Dep't Oktober 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 2, 2026

Late notice of claim

Supreme Court providently exercised its discretion in denying leave to file a late notice of claim, as petitioner failed to sustain his burden of establishing that respondent The City of New York had actual knowledge of the essential facts of his claim within 90 days of accrual or within a reasonable time afterward. The police accident report, the record of petitioner's arrest, and the criminal complaint against petitioner did not confer actual knowledge of the essential facts of petitioner's claims; rather, these documents established only that police officers were present on the scene, and that petitioner's motorcycle crashed into a stopped police vehicle while he was travelling at high speed in the wrong direction. These assertions are insufficient to establish actual knowledge by the City of the facts alleged in petitioner's notice of claim, as the documents make no mention of acts that would constitute actionable wrongdoing by any police officers.

In addition, petitioner failed to sustain his burden of showing that the City was not prejudiced by the delay in filing. In order to demonstrate absence of prejudice, petitioner relies solely on the City's purported actual knowledge, concluding that because the City had such knowledge, it did not experience substantial prejudice from petitioner's delay in serving the notice of claim. However, as petitioner failed to sustain his burden of showing that the City had actual knowledge of the essential facts of his claims, the burden never shifted to the City to make a particularized showing of prejudice.

Finally, petitioner did not provide any medical records or other evidence corroborating his claim of incapacity. As a result, he failed to provide a reasonable excuse for his delay of serving a notice of claim His purported incapacity is also undercut by his own affidavit, in which he averred that he was still able to attend court appearances and medical treatments, and would have timely served his notice of claim had he been aware of the 90-day requirement.

Matter of Connolly vs. City of New York, NY Slip Op 06383 (1st Dep't October 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

November 1, 2026

Admissibility of business records

The trial court properly excluded from evidence a non-party's invoices which plaintiff sought to admit as business records without supporting testimony from a representative of the non-party. Absent testimony from the non-party, plaintiff was required to establish through testimony or otherwise that it had knowledge of the non-party's business or billing practices or routinely used the invoices in its own business. As plaintiff did not make this showing, the invoices did not qualify for the business record exception, pursuant to CPLR 4518. In any event, the excluded invoices were not relevant, given that they did not purport to describe any defects or damage allegedly caused by defendant.

901 Props., LLC vs. Bear Glass, Inc., NY Slip Op 06380 (1st Dep't October 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 31, 2026

Preliminary injunction

In order to establish the right to a preliminary injunction, a movant must demonstrate: (1) the likelihood of success on the merits; (2) irreparable injury absent the injunction; and (3) that the equities balance in the movant's favor. The purpose of a preliminary injunction is to maintain the status quo, not to determine the ultimate rights of the parties. Motions for preliminary injunctions pursuant to CPLR 6301 must be made prior to the expiration of the cure period.

217-20 K&A, LLC vs. De Maio Props., LLC, NY Slip Op 06272 (2d Dep't October 28, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 30, 2026

Attorney affirmations

The affirmation of a party's attorney who demonstrates no personal knowledge of the matter at issue has no evidentiary value.

Vega vs. Archdiocese of New York, NY Slip Op 06270 (1st Dep't October 27, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 29, 2026

Striking a pleading

Defendant's repeated non-compliance with court orders without reasonable excuse warrants striking her answer, especially where at least one prior order warned of the possibility of such a penalty. Defendant's pro se status provides no excuse for non-compliance with her discovery obligations.

Abuzaid vs. Almayouf, NY Slip Op 06238 (1st Dep't October 27, 2026) 

Here is the decision. 

October 28, 2026

Medical malpractice

Supreme Court providently dismissed the medical malpractice claim pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.27 since plaintiff had not submitted expert medical opinion evidence necessary to demonstrate that she had a meritorious cause of action. The same cannot be said for the negligence and negligent hiring, retention, and supervision claims since the merits of those claims, which were asserted in the complaint and the bills of particulars, can be gleaned from the record.

Dupree vs. New York-Presbyterian Columbia Univ. Irving Med. Ctr., NY Slip Op 06242 (1st Dep't October 27, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 27, 2026

Judicial estoppel

It is well-settled New York law that a party who assumes a certain position in a legal proceeding may not thereafter assume a contrary position simply because his interests have changed.

Federal Natl. Mtge. Assn. vs. Hartsfield, NY Slip Op 06199 (1st Dep't October 22, 2026)

Here is the decision,.

October 26, 2026

Negligence claims

A defendant moving for summary judgment in a negligence action has the burden of establishing, prima facie, that he was not at fault in the happening of the accident at issue. Although there may be more than one proximate cause of an accident and proximate cause is generally an issue to be determined by the trier of fact, the issue of proximate cause may be decided as a matter of law where only one conclusion may be drawn from the established facts.

Burton vs. Gurung, NY Slip Op 06088 (2d Dep't October 21, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 25, 2026

Default judgments

Supreme Court appropriately denied petitioner's motion for a default judgment, as he moved for relief while the MTA's cross-motion to dismiss was still pending, pursuant to CPLR 7804[f].

Matter of Debnam vs. Metropolitan Transp. Auth., NY Slip Op 06196 (1st Dep't October 22, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 24, 2026

Brokers' commissions

Where an agreement between a landlord and non-party tenant states that the plaintiff is the exclusive broker for the transaction and that the defendant will pay its commission, that representation, supported by documentary evidence, entitles the plaintiff to its commission as a matter of law. The lease renewal agreement between defendant landlord and non-party tenant states that plaintiff is the exclusive broker and that defendant will pay the broker fees relating to the transaction. Defendant's contention that there was no binding agreement or privity between itself and plaintiff is expressly contradicted by this renewal agreement. Plaintiff also submitted emails with defendant's representative showing plaintiff's involvement in the lease negotiations. The court properly rejected defendant's contention that its refusal to execute a subsequent brokerage agreement after the renewal agreement was signed negated its express agreement to pay the commission.

Colliers Intl. NY, LLC vs. City Hall Commons, LLC, NY Slip Op 06195 (1st Dep't October 22, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 23, 2026

Expert opinions

An expert should be possessed of the requisite skill, training, education, knowledge, or experience from which it can be assumed that the information imparted or the opinion rendered is reliable.  The admissibility of expert testimony on a particular point is addressed to the discretion of the trial court.

Apuzzo vs. Central Cabinets, LLC, NY Slip Op 06082 (2d Dep't October 21, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 22, 2026

Mandamus

Mandamus to compel may only be used to enforce a clear legal right where the public official has failed to perform a duty enjoined by law. Mandamus is appropriate to compel public officers to perform ministerial duties but not discretionary acts. A discretionary act involves the exercise of reasoned judgment which could typically produce different acceptable results whereas a ministerial act envisions direct adherence to a governing rule or standard with a compulsory result.

Matter of Troise vs. Marchiano, NY Slip Op 06079 (1st Dep't October 20, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 21, 2026

Contracts

The construction and interpretation of an unambiguous written contract is an issue of law within the province of the court, as is the inquiry, in the first instance, of whether the writing is ambiguous. If the language is free from ambiguity, its meaning may be determined as a matter of law on the basis of the writing alone without resort to extrinsic evidence. An award of attorneys' fees for the costs incurred in prosecuting a claim for fees, so-called fees on fees, must be based upon a specific contractual provision or statute. Consequently, where a party is under no legal duty to indemnify, a contract assuming that obligation must be strictly construed to avoid reading into it a duty which the parties did not intend to be assumed.

Davidoff vs. Hershfield, NY Slip Op 05931 (2d Dep't October 14, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 20, 2026

Law of the case

The law of the case doctrine applies to legal determinations that were necessarily resolved on the merits in a prior decision, and to the same questions presented in the same case. It bars reconsideration of issues which were raised and determined against a party or which could have been raised on a prior appeal. An appellate court's resolution of an issue on a prior appeal constitutes the law of the case and is binding on the Supreme Court, as well as on the appellate court, and operates to foreclose re-examination of the question absent a showing of subsequent evidence or change of law.

Board of Mgrs. of Oceanview Condominium vs. Riccardi, NY Slip Op 05927 (2d Dep't October 14, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 19, 2026

Appellate practice

Defendant K Mart's contention that defendant Transform KM did not breach a duty to the plaintiff is not properly before the Appellate Division, as that issue was not decided in the order appealed from.

Beale vs. K Mart Corp., NY Slip Op 05926 (2d Dep't October 14, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 18, 2026

Unjust enrichment

Practice point:  Unjust enrichment lies as a quasi-contract claim and contemplates an obligation imposed by equity to prevent injustice, in the absence of an actual agreement between the parties. A valid contract governing the subject matter generally precludes recovery in quasi contract for events arising out of the same subject matter. 

Application:  Since there is a valid contract governing the subject matter, the complaint failed to state a cause of action to recover damages for unjust enrichment.

Alexim Holdings, LLC vs. Chang-Wardi, NY Slip Op 05924 (2d Dep't October 14, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 17, 2026

A receptionist's accepting service

Practice point:  A receptionist may accept service on behalf of a party if granted authority to do so.

Application:  The individual defendant asserted in his affidavit that neither his receptionist nor the building's receptionist was permitted to accept service. However, this statement contradicts the process server's affidavits of service. Thus, he has not conclusively established that his receptionist or the front desk receptionist was not permitted to accept service. 

City of New York vs. Heritage Health & Hous., Inc., NY Slip Op 05998 (1st Dep't October 15, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 16, 2026

Time to serve summons and complaint

Practice point:  Generally, service of a summons and complaint must be made within 120 days after the commencement of the action. Pursuant to CPLR 306-b, a court may, in the exercise of discretion, grant an extension of time within which to effect service for good cause shown or in the interest of justice.The more flexible interest of justice standard accommodates late service that might be due to mistake, confusion, or oversight, so long as there is no prejudice to the defendant. In considering the interest of justice standard, the court may consider diligence, or lack thereof, along with any other relevant factor, including expiration of the Statute of Limitations, the meritorious nature of the cause of action, the length of delay in service, the promptness of a plaintiff's request for the extension of time, and prejudice to the defendant.

Application:  The Supreme Court providently exercised its discretion in granting the plaintiff's motion in the interest of justice, and properly determined that dismissal of complaint insofar as asserted against the defendant pursuant to CPLR 306-b and 3211(a)(8) on the ground of the plaintiff's failure to serve the defendant with the summons and complaint was not warranted. The plaintiff demonstrated that the action was timely commenced, that service was timely attempted and was believed by the plaintiff to have been made within 120 days after the commencement of the action, but was subsequently found to be defective, and that the extension of time would not prejudice the defendant. Additionally, the plaintiff demonstrated a potentially meritorious cause of action.

Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. vs. Hall, NY Slip Op 05932 (2d Dep't October 14, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 15, 2026

Contract law

Practice point:  When a party repudiates contractual duties prior to the time designated for performance and before all of the consideration has been fulfilled, the repudiation entitles the non-repudiating party to claim damages for total breach.  

Application:  The record establishes that defendants repudiated the contract by issuing a change order requesting additional payments followed by a threat to not return to the job unless plaintiffs agreed to pay the initial amount demanded, which threat was fulfilled when they abandoned the project. Defendants' largely conclusory allegations of plaintiffs' delays fail to raise material issues of fact sufficient to preclude a grant of summary judgment.

Ho vs. Star Contrs., Inc., NY Slip Op 05908 (1st Dep't October 13, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 14, 2026

Defaults

Practice point:  Pursuant to CPLR 3215(c), "[i]f the plaintiff fails to take proceedings for the entry of judgment within one year after the default, the court shall not enter judgment but shall dismiss the complaint as abandoned . . . unless sufficient cause is shown why the complaint should not be dismissed." The language of CPLR 3215(c) is not, in the first instance, discretionary, but mandatory. In order to establish sufficient cause, the plaintiff must proffer a reasonable excuse for the delay in timely moving for a default judgment and demonstrate that the cause of action is potentially meritorious.

Application:  Initially, contrary to the Supreme Court's determination, it was not precluded from considering the defendant's cross-motion pursuant to CPLR 3215(c) to dismiss the complaint insofar as asserted against her as abandoned pursuant to the doctrine of law of the case. The order dated January 3, 2019, did not resolve on the merits whether the plaintiff abandoned the action pursuant to CPLR 3215(c). Further, the plaintiff failed to proffer a reasonable excuse for its lengthy delay in seeking a default judgment. The plaintiff's conclusory and unsubstantiated assertions that periods of delay were attributable to "loss mitigation discussions with [the] Borrower," compliance with a then newly-issued administrative order, and a change in counsel were insufficient to constitute a reasonable excuse. Since the plaintiff failed to set forth a reasonable excuse, the Appellate Division need not determine whether it asserted a potentially meritorious cause of action.

Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. vs. Faies, NY Slip Op 05767 (2d Dep't October 7, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 13, 2026

Statute of limitations as a defense

Practice point:  The doctrine of equitable estoppel applies where it would be unjust to allow a defendant to assert a statute of limitations defense. Thus, the defense of statute of limitations may be precluded where it is the defendant's affirmative wrongdoing that produced the long delay between the accrual of the cause of action and the commencement of the legal proceeding.

Application:  The defendants' admissions in their moving papers, together with the plaintiff's submissions in opposition to the motion, demonstrated that the plaintiff's delay in the commencement of this action was the result of the defendants' misconduct during the limitations period, and, therefore, that equitable estoppel is appropriate as a matter of law. The Supreme Court properly denied that branch of the defendants' motion which was, in effect, for summary judgment dismissing the complaint insofar as asserted against them as time-barred.

Bank of Am., N.A. vs. Russell, NY Slip Op 05759 (2d Dep't October 7, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 11, 2026

Contract law

Practice Point:  The essential elements of a cause of action to recover damages for breach of contract are: (1) the existence of a contract; (2) the plaintiff's performance pursuant to the contract; (3) the defendant's breach of its contractual obligations; and (4) damages resulting from the breach. A contract is to be construed in accordance with the parties' intent, which generally is discerned from the four corners of the document itself. Consequently, a written agreement that is complete, clear and unambiguous on its face must be enforced according to the plain meaning of its terms. A written agreement or other written instrument which contains a provision to the effect that it cannot be changed orally, cannot be changed by an executory agreement unless it is in writing and signed by the party against whom enforcement of the change is sought or by its agent. Notwithstanding that, an alleged oral modification is enforceable if there is part performance that is unequivocally referable to the oral modification. In order to be unequivocally referable, conduct must be inconsistent with any other explanation,

Application:  In support of their motion for summary judgment, the defendants established entitlement to judgment as a matter of law dismissing the cause of action alleging breach of contract against Titan by submitting evidence establishing, prima facie, that there had been no breach by Titan and that the plaintiffs were in default under the terms of the agreements by failing to repay the loans that matured in January 2020. In opposition, the plaintiffs failed to raise a triable issue of fact. Contrary to the plaintiffs' contention, the evidence did not raise a triable issue of fact as to whether Titan's acceptance of payments in June and July 2020 reflected a new oral contract.

White vs. Titan Capital ID, LLC, NY Slip Op 05826 (2d Dep't October 7, 2026) 

Here is the decision. 

October 10, 2026

Usury as a defense

Practice point:  Establishing that there was a loan is a necessary element of a defense sounding in usury. 

Application:  Defendants failed to establish that the underlying agreement was a loan, in failing to demonstrate, among other things, that the agreement had a finite term.

Kapitus Servicing, Inc. vs. Southern Source, Inc., NY Slip Op 05855 (1st Dep't October 8, 2026) 

 Here is the decision.

October 9, 2026

Fiduciary relationships

Practice point:  There is a fiduciary relationship between two persons when one of them is under a duty to act for or to give advice for the benefit of another upon matters within the scope of the relation.

Application:  The parties' personal relationship alone does not give rise to a fiduciary relationship.

Goldberg vs. Torim, NY Slip Op 05721 (1st Dep't October 6, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 8, 2026

Stipulations

Practice point:  A stipulation is binding on parties that have legal capacity to negotiate, freely negotiate their agreement, and either reduce their stipulation to a properly subscribed writing or enter the stipulation orally on the record in open court.

Application:  The plaintiff's own submissions raised issues of fact as to the legal capacity of the plaintiff's attorney to enter into a stipulation on behalf of the decedent's estate and to sell any interest the decedent's estate may have in the property at issue. The plaintiff's motion to enforce the terms of the stipulation and to appoint a referee to sell the property is denied.

Estate of Coba vs. Hernandez, NY Slip Op 05517 (2d Dep't September 30, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 7, 2026

Sua sponte dismissal

Practice point:  A court's power to dismiss an action, sua sponte, is to be used sparingly and only when extraordinary circumstances warrant dismissal.

Application:  The plaintiff's failure to comply with the directive in the status conference order did not warrant dismissal of the complaint.

Deutsche Natl. Bank Trust Co. vs. Mohamed, NY Slip Op 05516 (2d Dep't September 30, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 6, 2026

Contract law

Practice point:  A contract is unambiguous if the language it uses has a definite and precise meaning, unattended by danger of misconception in the purport of the agreement itself, and concerning which there is no reasonable basis for a difference of opinion. The threshold question of whether a contract is unambiguous and the subsequent construction and interpretation of an unambiguous contract are issues of law within the province of the motion court.

Application:  The Supreme Court properly determined that the relevant provisions of the agreement regarding the imposition of a Transfer Fee, when read in context, were clear and unambiguous, and established that the defendant was prohibited from imposing the fee on the plaintiff pursuant to the terms of the agreement.

Data Mtge., Inc. vs. Money Source, Inc., NY Slip Op 05514 (2d Dep't September 30, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 5, 2026

Employment law

Practice point:  Actions alleging discrimination under State and City Human Rights Laws must be commenced within three years after the alleged unlawful discriminatory practice or act of discriminatory harassment. An employment discrimination claim accrues on the date that an adverse employment determination is made and communicated to the plaintiff.

Application:  On or about July 16, 2014, the defendant notified the plaintiff and the New York City Department of Citywide Administrative Services that after an investigation, the plaintiff failed to establish his entitlement to a disabled veteran's credit, pursuant to Civil Service Law § 85, thereby starting the running of the applicable statute of limitations. The plaintiff's written request seeking reconsideration of the defendant's decision to withdraw the plaintiff's disabled veteran's credit did not toll the statute of limitations, nor did it allow the plaintiff to circumvent the statute of limitations by demanding that the defendant change its determination and thereafter commencing an action when that demand was refused. The plaintiff commenced this action on March 15, 2019, almost five years after the defendant notified the plaintiff that he was ineligible for a disabled veteran's credit. 

Dismissed.

Bourke vs. City of New York, NY Slip Op 05513 (2d Dep't September 30, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 4, 2026

Arbitration awards

Practice point:  CPLR 7511(e) mandates an automatic confirmation upon denial of a motion to vacate or modify an arbitration award.

Application:  Supreme Court denied the petition to vacate the arbitration award, deemed the motion to dismiss the petition to be a motion to confirm the award, and granted the motion. The Appellate Division affirmed, noting that a motion to confirm was not necessary.

Matter of ReductoNox Corp. vs. Siemens Energy, Inc., NY Slip Op 05613 (1st Dep't October 1, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 3, 2026

Landlord-tenant

Practice point:  Tenants may challenge the purportedly deregulated status of their apartment at any time during their tenancy, and the apartment's rent history may be examined beyond four years to determine whether it remains rent-stabilized.

Application:  According to defendant, the last rent-controlled rent was approximately $620 per month, but defendant asserted a first rent following decontrol of $2,100 per month beginning in 2011, $100 above the deregulation threshold in effect at the time. However, the affidavit of a member of defendant's managing agent that defendant submitted in support of its cross-motion for summary judgment failed to authenticate as admissible business records the documents offered as proof of the foregoing facts. Accordingly, defendant failed to make a prima facie showing of entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, and its cross-motion for summary judgment should have been denied regardless of the sufficiency of the opposing papers.

Petrolowicz vs. Ando Realty, LLC, NY Slip Op 05611 (1st Dep't October 1, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 2, 2026

Foreclosures

Practice point:  In order to establish prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law in a foreclosure action, a plaintiff must submit the mortgage and unpaid note, along with evidence of the default. A plaintiff can establish a default by submission of an affidavit from a person having personal knowledge of the facts, or other evidence in admissible form. The business record exception to the hearsay rule applies to a writing or record, and it is the business record itself, not the foundational affidavit, that serves as proof of the matter asserted. Without the introduction of the records themselves, a witness's testimony as to the contents of the records is inadmissible hearsay.

Application:  The Supreme Court should have denied those branches of the plaintiff's motion which were for summary judgment on the complaint insofar as asserted against the defendants and for an order of reference on the ground that the plaintiff failed to establish, prima facie, the defendants' default in payment.  In an affidavit of the plaintiff's vice president, which the plaintiff submitted in support of its motion for summary judgment on the complaint insofar as asserted against the defendants and for an order of reference, The affiant  did not aver that he had personal knowledge of the defendants' alleged default in payment. To the extent that his knowledge was based on his review of business records, he did not identify what records he relied on and he did not attach them to his affidavit. Thus, the plaintiff failed to submit evidence in admissible form to establish the defendants' default. Since the plaintiff failed to establish the defendants' default in payment, it failed to establish its prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, as well as its entitlement to an order of reference and a judgment of foreclosure and sale.

Banc of Cal., N.A. vs. Plumbing Supply Distributor., LLC, NY Slip Op 05510 (2d Dep't September 30, 2026)

Here is the decision.

October 1, 2026

Premises liability

Practice point:  In a premises liability case, a defendant-property owner who moves for summary judgment has the initial burden of making a prima facie showing that it neither created the alleged defective condition nor had actual or constructive notice of it. However, a property owner has no duty to protect or warn against conditions that are open and obvious and not inherently dangerous. A condition is open and obvious if it is readily observable by those employing the reasonable use of their senses, given the conditions at the time of the accident.

Application:  The defendant established its prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law dismissing the complaint by demonstrating that the air conditioning unit protruding from the window was open and obvious and not inherently dangerous. In opposition, the plaintiffs failed to raise a triable issue of fact.

Hoefler vs. Shoreham-Wading Riv. Cent. Sch. Dist., NY Slip Op 05384 (2d Dep't September 23, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 30, 2026

Appellate practice

Practice point:  The death of a party terminates the attorney's authority to act on behalf of the deceased party. 

Application:  The plaintiff died after the commencement of this action, and no substitution was effected. Nevertheless, counsel that had represented the plaintiff prior to his death purportedly took this appeal on his behalf. Since counsel lacks the authority to act on the plaintiff's behalf, the appeal purportedly taken on the plaintiff's behalf must be dismissed.

Guthrie vs. New York-Presbyt. Brooklyn Methodist Hosp., NY Slip Op 05383 (2d Dep't September 23, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 29, 2026

Contract law

Practice point. Generally, a contractual obligation, standing alone, will not give rise to tort liability in favor of a third party. However, a party that enters into a contract to render services may be said to have assumed a duty of care, and, thus, be potentially liable in tort to third persons, where: (1) the contracting party, in failing to exercise reasonable care in the performance of its duties, launches a force or instrument of harm; (2) the plaintiff detrimentally relies on the continued performance of the contracting party's duties; or (3) the contracting party has entirely displaced the other party's duty to maintain the premises safely. If any of the exceptions are pleaded in the complaint or the bill of particulars, a defendant contractor is required to demonstrate that those pleaded exceptions do not apply in order to establish its prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law.

Application: The Supreme Court properly granted that branch of City-Wide's motion which was for summary judgment dismissing the cross-claims asserted against it. Viewed in the light most favorable to the restaurant defendants, as the nonmoving parties, the complaint in Action No. 1, the second amended complaint in Action No. 2, and the bills of particulars alleged the first of the three exceptions. In support to its motion, City-Wide established, prima facie, that neither the police plaintiffs nor the decedent were parties to any agreement between it and Legal Sea Foods, and that the repair work it performed four days prior to the incident neither launched an instrument of harm nor created or exacerbated the alleged dangerous condition at the restaurant.

Fezza vs. Legal Sea Foods, LLC, NY Slip Op 05382 (2d Dep't September 23, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 28, 2026

Personal jurisdiction

Practice point:  A defendant may waive the issue of lack of personal jurisdiction by appearing in an action, either formally or informally, without raising the defense of lack of personal jurisdiction in an answer or pre-answer motion to dismiss. A defendant appears formally by serving an answer or a notice of appearance, or by making a motion which has the effect of extending the time to answer. A defendant may appear informally by actively litigating the action before the court.

Application:  The defendant's participation in settlement conferences pursuant to CPLR 3408 and the limited notice of appearance filed for that purpose did not demonstrate a clear intent to participate in the lawsuit on the merits, and, thus, did not constitute a formal or informal appearance. However, the defendant's counsel later filed a general notice of appearance, and did not move to dismiss the complaint on the ground of lack of personal jurisdiction at that time or assert lack of personal jurisdiction in a responsive pleading. By waiting another 3½ years before making a cross-motion to dismiss the complaint insofar as asserted against her for lack of personal jurisdiction, the defendant waived any claim that the Supreme Court lacked personal jurisdiction over her. The defendant's contention that the plaintiff waived this issue by failing to raise it in opposition to the cross-motion or at the hearing to determine the validity of service of process upon the defendant is without merit.

Accordingly, since the defendant waived the issue of lack of personal jurisdiction, the Supreme Court erred in granting that branch of the defendant's motion which was to restore to the calendar that branch of her cross-motion which was to dismiss the complaint insofar as asserted against her for lack of personal jurisdiction, and, in effect, granting that branch of the cross-motion.

Federal Natl. Mtge. Assn. vs. Cassis, NY Slip Op 05381 (2d Dep't September 23, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 27, 2026

Summary judgment motions

There is no merit to the defendants' contention that the motion should have been denied as premature because discovery had yet to take place, pursuant to CPLR 3212[f]). It is well-settled that the mere hope or speculation that evidence sufficient to defeat a motion for summary judgment may be uncovered during the discovery process is insufficient to deny the motion. Moreover, the defendants failed to demonstrate that the relevant facts were in the plaintiff's exclusive control.

Bank of Am., N.A. vs. Discobath Prods., Inc., NY Slip Op 05377 (2d Dep't September 23, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 26, 2026

Appellate practice

Plaintiff abandoned his appeal of the dismissal of the cause of action seeking inspection of the condominium board's records. Supreme Court dismissed this cause of action for plaintiff's lack of standing, and plaintiff's argument on appeal with respect to the issue of standing was limited to the two derivative causes of action.

Bent vs. Cirone, NY Slip Op 05456 (1st Dep't September 24, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 25, 2026

Contract law

Where a seller seeks to hold a purchaser in breach of contract, the seller must establish that it was ready, willing, and able to perform on the time-of-the-essence closing date, and that the purchaser failed to demonstrate a lawful excuse for its failure to close. In light of the plaintiff's contractual obligations at closing, its bare assertion that it tendered the deed in the defendants' absence was insufficient to establish, prima facie, that the plaintiff was ready, willing, and able to perform on the adjourned closing date. 

1539 Realty, LLC vs. Murphy, NY Slip Op 05376 (2d Dep't September 23, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 24, 2026

Contract law

Contract interpretation is a question of law subject to de novo review. A complete, clear, and unambiguous agreement must be enforced according to its plain terms. Courts seek the parties' reasonable expectations, giving words their fair meaning in context.

Aurelius Capital Master Ltd. vs. Hertz Intl. Ltd., NY Slip Op 05369 (1st Dep't September 22, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 23, 2026

Venue

Pursuant to CPLR 503(a), "[e]xcept where otherwise prescribed by law, the place of trial shall be in the county in which one of the parties resided when it was commenced; [or] the county in which a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred." CPLR 510(3) provides that, upon motion, the court may change the venue of an action where "the convenience of material witnesses and the ends of justice will be promoted by the change." A party moving to change venue pursuant to CPLR 510(3) must provide information about the prospective witnesses, including, but not limited to, their names and addresses, disclose the facts about which the proposed witnesses will testify at the trial, represent that the prospective witnesses are willing to testify, and state that the witnesses would be inconvenienced if the venue is not changed. The situs of a plaintiff's injury may provide a basis for a discretionary change of venue in that, things being equal, a transitory action should be tried in the county where the cause of action arose.

Bellavia vs. Hoppenstein, NY Slip Op 05267 (2d Dep't September 16, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 22, 2026

Premises liability

Under the storm in progress rule, a property owner will not be held liable in negligence for a plaintiff's injuries sustained as the result of an icy condition occurring during an ongoing storm or for a reasonable time thereafter.

Batista vs. Allerton Ave. Estates, LLC, NY Slip Op 05265 (2d Dep't September 16, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 21, 2026

Spoliation

Under the common-law doctrine of spoliation, when a party negligently loses or intentionally destroys key evidence, the responsible party may be sanctioned. The party seeking sanctions for spoliation must show that the party having control over the evidence was obliged to preserve it at the time of its destruction, that the evidence was destroyed with a culpable state of mind, and that the destroyed evidence was relevant to the party's claim or defense such that the trier of fact could find that the evidence would support that claim or defense.

The Supreme Court has broad discretion in determining what, if any, sanction is imposed for spoliation of evidence, but the Appellate Division may substitute its own discretion for that of the trial court. The nature and severity of the sanction depends upon a number of factors, including, but not limited to, the knowledge and intent of the spoliator, proof of an explanation for the loss of the evidence, and the degree of prejudice to the opposing party.

Alvarez vs. 100-10 67 Rd. Condominium, NY Slip Op 05261 (2d Dep't September 16, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 20, 2026

Contract law

The equitable remedy of specific performance is a discretionary remedy that provides an alternative to an award of damages as a means of enforcing a contract. The decision whether to grant or deny the remedy of specific performance lies within the discretion of the court. It should not be granted where it would cause unreasonable hardship or injustice.

90 Chicken Corp. v. 90 Jericho Realty Corp., NY Slip Op 05258 (2d Dep't September 16, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 19, 2026

Contract law

Lease provisions purporting to exempt a lessor from liability for its own negligence are void as against public policy. However, where sophisticated parties, negotiating at arm's length, have agreed to allocate between themselves the risk of liability to third parties, through insurance, the agreement is enforceable.

Hearns v. Blended Family, LLC, NY Slip Op 05367 (1st Dep't September 17, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 18, 2026

Appellate practice

In reviewing a determination made after a non-jury trial, the Appellate Division's power is as broad as that of the trial court. The Appellate Division may render the judgment it finds warranted by the facts, taking into account that, in a close case, the trial judge had the advantage of seeing the witnesses.

90 Chicken Corp. v. 90 Jericho Realty Corp., NY Slip Op 05258 (2d Dep't September 16, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 17, 2026

Contract law

A stipulation of settlement which is incorporated but not merged into a judgment of divorce is a contract subject to principles of contract construction and interpretation. A court should interpret the stipulation in accordance with its plain and ordinary meaning, and arrive at a construction that will give fair meaning to the contractual language so that the parties' reasonable expectations will be realized. A court may not write into a contract conditions the parties did not insert by adding or excising terms under the guise of construction, and it may not construe the language in such a way as would distort the contract's apparent meaning. In making the determination, the court should examine the entire contract and consider the relation of the parties and the circumstances under which the contract was executed.

Graudins v. Hunt, NY Slip Op 05168 (2d Dep't Septrember 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 16, 2026

Motions to dismiss

In considering a motion pursuant to CPLR 3211(a)(7) to dismiss a complaint for failure to state a cause of action, the court must afford the pleading a liberal construction, accept the facts as alleged in the pleading as true, accord the plaintiff the benefit of every possible favorable inference, and determine only whether the facts as alleged fit within any cognizable legal theory. Where evidentiary material is submitted and considered on a motion to dismiss a complaint pursuant to CPLR 3211(a)(7), and the motion is not converted into one for summary judgment, the question becomes whether the plaintiff has a cause of action, not whether the plaintiff has stated one.

Gooding v. Bank of N.Y. Mellon, NY Slip Op 05167 (2d Dep't September 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 15, 2026

A deceased mortgagor

A party may not commence a legal action or proceeding against a dead person. Thus, when a mortgagor dies prior to the commencement of a foreclosure action, the action is a legal nullity, unless the action is commenced against the personal representative of the mortgagor's estate.

Federal Natl. Mtge. Assn. v. Gooch, NY Slip Op 05165 (2d Dep't September 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 14, 2026

Dismissal based on documentary evidence

A party may move to dismiss a complaint pursuant to CPLR 3211(a)(1) where the movant has a defense founded on documentary evidence. The evidence submitted in support of the motion must be documentary or the motion must be denied. Emails do not qualify as documentary evidence.

Druzhinsky v. Trump Vil. Section 4, Inc., NY Slip Op 05164 (2d Dep't September 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 13, 2026

Appellate practice

The appeal from the order must be dismissed because the right of direct appeal therefrom terminated with the entry of the judgment in the action.

Druzhinsky v. Trump Vil. Section 4, Inc., NY Slip Op 05163 (2d Dep't September 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 12, 2026

Premises liability

Premises liability, as with liability for negligence generally, begins with duty. It is for the court to determine whether any duty exists, taking into consideration the reasonable expectations of the parties and society in general. The scope of any such duty of care varies with the foreseeability of possible harm. Generally, liability for a dangerous condition on real property must be predicated upon ownership, occupancy, control, or special use of the property.

Cox v. Cove 5, LLC, NY Slip Op 05160 (2d Dep't September 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 10, 2026

Arbitration provisions

Arbitration is a matter of contract, grounded in an agreement between the parties. Thus, when deciding whether the parties agreed to arbitrate a certain matter, the court will apply the principles that govern the formation of contracts. If the parties have broadly agreed to arbitrate any dispute arising out of a contract, the court's sole inquiry is whether there is a reasonable relationship between the subject matter of the dispute and the general subject matter of the underlying contract.

Under contract law, the general rule is that only a party to an arbitration agreement is bound by or may enforce the agreement. However, an assignee of a contract may avail itself of an arbitration clause contained therein.

Breslin Brookhaven, LLC v. Rose, NY Slip Op 05156 (2d Dep't September 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 9, 2026

Medical malpractice

To establish a cause of action to recover damages based on lack of informed consent, a plaintiff must prove: (1) the treatment provider failed to inform the patient of reasonably foreseeable risks associated with the treatment, and the alternatives thereto; (2) a reasonably prudent patient, if fully informed, would not have undergone the treatment; and (3) the lack of informed consent is a proximate cause of the injury. The mere fact that the plaintiff signed a consent form does not establish the defendants' prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law. 

Boutereira v. Grotas, NY Slip Op 05155 (2d Dep't September 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 8, 2026

Contract law

New York courts routinely enforce liability-limitation provisions, especially when negotiated by sophisticated parties. The Appellate Division has recognized an exception to this general rule in cases where a party's alleged misconduct smacks of intentional wrongdoing that is fraudulent, malicious, or prompted by the sinister intention of a party acting in bad faith. The type of intentional wrongdoing that could render a contractual limitation unenforceable is that which is unrelated to any legitimate economic self-interest. Where the conduct in question was undertaken to advance a legitimate economic self-interest, a party is entitled to rely on the contractual limitation provision, notwithstanding the intentional nature of its actions.

Jeffries, LLC v. Mountain State Energy Holdings, LLC, NY Slip Op 05232 (1st Dep't September 3, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 7, 2026

Dismissal as abandoned

Pursuant to CPLR 3215(c), "[i]f the plaintiff fails to take proceedings for the entry of judgment within one year after the default, the court shall not enter judgment but shall dismiss the complaint as abandoned . . . unless sufficient cause is shown why the complaint should not be dismissed."  In order to avoid dismissal pursuant to the statute, it is not necessary for a plaintiff to actually obtain a default judgment within one year of the default. As long as proceedings are being taken, and these proceedings manifest an intent not to abandon the case but to seek a judgment, the case is not subject to dismissal. Once the plaintiff establishes that it had initiated proceedings for the entry of a judgment within one year, it is in compliance with CPLR 3215(c) and is not required to account for any additional periods of delay subsequent to the initial one-year period.

Aurora Loan Servs., LLC v. Miller, NY Slip Op 05153 (2d Dep't September 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 6, 2026

Judicial conduct

Judicial remarks that are critical or disapproving of, or even hostile to, counsel, the parties, or their cases do not support a bias or partiality challenge.

Beach v. Touradji Capital Mgt., L.P., NY Slip Op 05231 (1st Dep't September 3, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 5, 2026

Arbitration awards

Under CPLR 7511, a party may move to vacate or modify an award if it demonstrates by clear and convincing proof that its rights were prejudiced by the arbitrator's partiality. Partiality can be established by proof of actual bias or the appearance of bias from which a conflict of interest may be inferred. 

Matter of 57th & 6th Ground, LLC v. Carnegie House Tenants Corp., NY Slip Op 05230 (1st Dep't September 3, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 4, 2026

Property law

RPAPL 1371(2) specifies, in pertinent part, as follows: "Simultaneously with the making of a motion for an order confirming the sale, . . . the party to whom [a deficiency] shall be owing may make a motion in the action for leave to enter a deficiency judgment upon notice to the party against whom such judgment is sought or the attorney who shall have appeared for such party in such action. Such notice shall be served personally or in such other manner as the court may direct."

Here, the plaintiff's electronic filing of the motion papers on the New York State Courts Electronic Filing System did not constitute proper service in accordance with RPAPL 1371(2). This constitutes a complete bar to the entry of a deficiency judgment.

11-36 31st Ave. Lender, LLC v. RM Newman, LLC, NY Slip Op 05151 (2d Dep't September 2, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 3, 2026

Contract law

In New York, to establish its prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law on a cause of action alleging breach of contract, a plaintiff is required to demonstrate the existence of a contract, the party's performance under the contract, the other party's breach of the contract, and harm suffered by the party as a result. An enforceable agreement requires an offer, acceptance of the offer, consideration, mutual assent, and an intent to be bound.

Banc of Am. Leasing & Capital, LLC v. Wooter Apparel, Inc., NY Slip Op 05069 (2d Dep't August 26, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 2, 2026

Dismissal for failure to prosecute

A court may not dismiss an action based on neglect to prosecute unless the CPLR 3216 statutory preconditions to dismissal are met. Pursuant to CPLR 3216(b), an action cannot be dismissed pursuant to CPLR 3216(a) unless a written demand is served upon the party against whom such relief is sought in accordance with the statutory requirements, along with a statement that non-compliance within 90 days will serve as a basis for a motion to dismiss. The statute also requires that where a written demand to resume prosecution of the action is made by the court, the demand shall set forth specific conduct demonstrating a pattern of delay in proceeding with the litigation.

Avanza Group, LLC v. Bugz Innovations, LLC, NY Slip Op 05068 (2d Dep't August 26, 2026)

Here is the decision.

September 1, 2026

Malpractice or negligence

Medical malpractice is a species of negligence. The distinction turns on whether the act complained of involves a matter of medical science or art requiring special skills not ordinarily possessed by lay persons, or whether the conduct complained of can be assessed on the basis of the common everyday experience of the trier of fact.  A claim sounds in medical malpractice when the challenged conduct constitutes medical treatment or bears a substantial relationship to the rendition of medical treatment by a licensed physician to a particular patient. When a plaintiff's allegations do not focus on negligence in furnishing medical treatment to a patient, but on a physician's failure in fulfilling a different duty, the claim sounds in ordinary negligence. In categorizing a claim for statute of limitations purposes, the court must focus on the essence of the claim, and, critically, identify the nature of the duty owed to the plaintiff that the defendant allegedly breached.

Lafferty v. Avila, NY Slip Op 05147 (1st Dep't August 27, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 31, 2026

Indemnification

A party bringing a common-law indemnification claim does not need to have a contractual relationship with the proposed indemnitor. However, the indemnitee's obligation to pay the plaintiff must be predicated either on liability by operation of law, such as vicarious liability, or on an existing relationship between the indemnitor and the indemnitee, such as in the case of a guarantor and principal. The key element of a common-law cause of action for indemnification is not a duty running from the indemnitor to the injured party, but is a separate duty owed the indemnitee by the indemnitor.

Fidelity Natl. Tit. Ins. Co. v. Sky Abstract Corp., NY Slip Op 05145 (1st Dep't August 27, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 30, 2026

Contract law

A defendant's contractual obligation, standing alone, will generally not give rise to tort liability in favor of a third party. There are exceptions to the general rule. A contracting party can assume a duty of care toward a third party where: 1) the contracting party, in failing to exercise reasonable care in the performance of its duties, launches a force or instrument of harm; 2) the plaintiff detrimentally relies on the continued performance of the contracting party's duties; or 3) the contracting party has entirely displaced the other party's duty to maintain the premises safely.

Carrero-Santiago v. Asphalt Green, Inc., NY Slip Op 05144 (1st Dep't August 27, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 29, 2026

Anti-suit injunctions

The court's power to issue an anti-suit injunction is rarely and sparingly employed. The injunction will issue only if there is danger of fraud or gross wrong being perpetrated on the foreign court.

Astraea NYNY, LLC v. Ganley, NY Slip Op 05143 (1st Dep't August 27, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 28, 2026

Failure to oppose

In order to vacate its default in timely opposing the plaintiffs' motion, the defendant was required to demonstrate a reasonable excuse for the default, as well as a potentially meritorious opposition to the motion, pursuant to CPLR 5015[a][1]. While CPLR 2005 allows courts to excuse a default due to law office failure, it was not the Legislature's intent to routinely excuse such defaults, and mere neglect will not be accepted as a reasonable excuse. Here, the Supreme Court did not improvidently exercise its discretion in rejecting the defendant's conclusory excuse of law office failure, which was part of a pattern of neglect demonstrated by the defendant during discovery.

Aladin v. Kensington Ins.Co., NY Slip Op 05067 (2d Dep't August 26, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 27, 2026

Premises liability

A landowner owes a duty of care to maintain the property in a reasonably safe condition. However, an out-of-possession landlord is not liable for injuries that occur on its premises unless the landlord has retained control over the premises and has a duty imposed by statute or assumed by contract or a course of conduct. Even if a defendant is considered an out-of-possession landlord who assumed the obligation to make repairs to its property, it cannot be held liable for injuries caused by a defective condition on the property unless it either created the condition or had actual or constructive notice of it.

Bracey v. 107-47 Sutphin, LLC, NY Slip Op 05003 (2d Dep't August 19, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 26, 2026

Appellate practice

The order is appealable, pursuant to CPLR 5511. It was not entered upon the defendants' default because, although the Supreme Court noted that it was entitled to disregard the defendants' untimely opposition papers, it considered the merits of the defendants' opposition. The appeal is not academic because its determination would directly affect the rights of the parties.

Bank of Am., N.A. v. Ragnauth, NY Slip Op 05001 (2d Dep't August 19, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 25, 2026

Default judgments

A plaintiff seeking leave to enter a default judgment must file proof of proper service of the summons and the complaint, the defendant's default, and the facts constituting the claim. A default judgment in a declaratory judgment action will not be granted on the default and pleadings alone, as it is necessary that plaintiff establish the right to a declaration.

Allstate Ins. Co,. v. Cabrera, NY Slip Op 05000 (2d Dep't August 19, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 24, 2026

Jurisdiction

Where a defendant seeking to vacate a default judgment raises a jurisdictional objection pursuant to CPLR 5015(a)(4), and seeks a discretionary vacatur pursuant to CPLR 5015(a)(1), the court is required to resolve the jurisdictional question before determining whether it is appropriate to grant the vacatur.

Allen v. Tilak, NY Slip Op 04999 (2d Dep't August 19, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 23, 2026

Contract law

In order to recover damages for breach of contract, the plaintiff must demonstrate that there is a contract, the plaintiff's performance pursuant to the contract, the defendant's breach of its contractual obligations, and damages resulting from the breach. A contract is to be construed in accordance with the parties' intent, which is discerned from the four corners of the document. Consequently, a written agreement that is complete, clear, and unambiguous on its face must be enforced according to the plain meaning of its terms. Contract language is ambiguous when it is reasonably susceptible of more than one interpretation, and extrinsic or parol evidence may be considered to determine the parties' intent.

206 Rte. 59 Holdings, LLC v. Boyiatzis Holdings Co., LLC, NY Slip Op 04998 (2d Dep't August 19, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 22, 2026

Appellate practice

The appeal from the order must be dismissed because the right of direct appeal therefrom terminated with the entry of an amended judgment in the action.

206 Rte. 59 Holdings, LLC v. Boyiatzis Holdings Co., LLC, NY Slip Op 04997 (2d Dep't August 19, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 21, 2026

Appellate practice

Defendants' common-law indemnification and contribution claims are deemed abandoned as they did not address those claims in either their opposition to the motion for summary judgment dismissing the claims or in their respondents' brief on the appeal.

Ambrose v. City Univ. Constr. Fund, NY Slip Op 05060 (1st Dep't August 20, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 20, 2026

Defaults

A professed ignorance of the law and a lack of understanding of the need to serve an answer does not constitute a reasonable excuse for the default.

Gaitanidis v. Perri Logan Equity, Inc., NY Slip Op 04931 (2d Dep't August 12, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 19, 2026

Jurisdictional defects

A judgment or order issued without subject matter jurisdiction is void. The defect may be raised at any time and may not be waived.

Federal Natl. Mtge. Assn. v. Jackson, NY Slip Op 04927 (2d Dep't August 12, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 18, 2026

Aiding and abetting breach of fiduciary duty

A defendant knowingly participates in the breach of fiduciary duty when it affirmatively assists, helps to conceal, or fails to act when required to do so, thereby enabling the breach. An allegation that the defendant merely came upon and exploited the situation after the breach occurred is insufficient.

Rossi Mktg. Group, Inc. v. Malin Group, Inc., NY Slip Op 04987 (1st Dep't August 13, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 17, 2026

Service of process

Ordinarily, the affidavit of a process server constitutes prima facie evidence that the defendant was validly served. Bare and unsubstantiated denials of receipt of the summons and complaint are insufficient to rebut the presumption of service. However, a sworn denial of service containing specific facts generally rebuts the presumption of proper service established by the process server's affidavit, and necessitates an evidentiary hearing.

Anglada v. Bradford, NY Slip Op 04917 (2d Dep't August 12, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 16, 2026

Inter vivos gifts

The elements necessary for a valid inter vivos gift are: (1) the donor's intent to make an irrevocable present transfer of ownership; (2) physical or constructive delivery, sufficient to divest the donor of dominion and control over the property; and (3) acceptance of the gift by the donee. The proponent of the purported gift has the burden of proving each of the elements by clear and convincing evidence.

Eng v. Eng, NY Slip Op 04840 (2d Dep't August 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 15, 2026

Law of the case

The doctrine of the law of the case operates to foreclose re-examination of the issue absent a showing of new factual circumstances, additional relevant evidence, or a change in the law that would warrant reconsideration of the issue. An appellate court's resolution of an issue on a prior appeal constitutes the law of the case and is binding on the Supreme Court, as well as on the appellate court.

DLJ Mtge. Capital, Inc. v. Pittman, NY Slip Op 04838 (2d Dep't August 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 14, 2026

Suing the State

Pursuant to Court of Claims Act § 11(b), a notice of intention to file a claim and a claim must set forth, among other things, the place where the claim arose. A failure to comply with the requirements set forth in the statute is a jurisdictional defect compelling dismissal of the claim.  Although § 11(b) does not require absolute exactness, it requires a statement made with sufficient definiteness to enable the State to be able to investigate the claim promptly and to ascertain its liability under the circumstances.

Dipolito v. State of New York, NY Slip Op 04837 (2d Dep't August 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 13, 2026

Contract law

 A release is a contract, and its construction is governed by contract law.

Board of Mgrs. of the Waterwheel Condominium, LLC v. Ardsley Waterwheel Partners, LLC, NY Slip Op 04834 (2d Dep't August 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 12, 2026

Summary judgment standard

The proponent of a summary judgment motion must make a prima facie showing of entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, tendering sufficient evidence to demonstrate the absence of any material issues of fact. Failure to make such prima facie showing requires a denial of the motion, regardless of the sufficiency of the opposing papers.

Armstrong v. Dumbo Lofts Rental, LLC, NY Slip Op 04832 (2d Dep't August 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 11, 2026

Dismissal of defenses

CPLR 3211(b) provides that "[a] party may move for judgment dismissing one or more defenses, on the ground that a defense is not stated or has no merit." When moving to dismiss, the plaintiff bears the burden of demonstrating that the affirmative defenses are without merit as a matter of law because they either do not apply under the facts, or fail to state a defense. On a motion pursuant to CPLR 3211(b), the court should apply the same standard it applies to a motion to dismiss pursuant to CPLR 3211(a)(7), and the factual assertions of the defense will be accepted as true. If there is any doubt as to the availability of a defense, it should not be dismissed.

Alava v. Buffalo Airport Car Rental, NY Slip Op 04830 (2d Dep't August 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 10, 2026

Failure to appear

In order to vacate the default in appearing for oral argument, the plaintiff was required to demonstrate a reasonable excuse for his default and a potentially meritorious opposition to the defendants' motion. The determination of what constitutes a reasonable excuse lies within the Supreme Court's discretion.  Law office failure may be accepted as a reasonable excuse, provided that it is supported by a detailed and credible explanation.

Aguilar v. Tona Constr. & Mgt., LLC, NY Slip Op 04829 (2d Dep't August 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 9, 2026

Failure to oppose

The proper procedure to cure a default in opposing a motion is to move pursuant to CPLR 5015(a) to vacate the default, and, if necessary, to appeal that determination. A motion denominated as one for leave to renew an unopposed motion may be construed as one to vacate the default.

Abingdon Realty Co., LLC v. Finkelshteyn, NY Slip Op 04828 (2d Dep't August 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 8, 2026

Leave to amend

Plaintiff's proposed amendment did not advance a new theory of liability but merely expounded on theories of liability already set forth in the prior bill.  There was no showing of sufficient surprise or prejudice to deny the amendment. The motion is granted.

Batchilly v. 610 8th Ave. Corp., NY Slip Op 04910 (1st Dep't August 6, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 7, 2026

Fees on fees

The portion of the award for legal fees and costs incurred by the defendant in prosecuting a claim for an award of attorneys' fees - so-called "fees on fees," for services performed to recover a fee award - generally must be based upon a specific contractual provision or statute. Where a contract provides for indemnification for "legal costs and charges, including counsel fees," the Appellate Division has determined that it does not provide for fees on fees in the absence of unmistakably clear intent regarding their recovery. However, both the Court of Appeals and the Appellate Division have authorized the inclusion of fees for prosecuting or defending an appeal dealing with an award of attorneys' fees.

21st Mtge. Corp. v Nweke, NY Slip Op 04826 (2d Dep't August 5, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 6, 2026

Employment law

An employer can be held liable under theories of negligent hiring, retention, and supervision where the complaint alleges that the employer knew or should have known of the employee's propensity for the conduct which caused the injury.

D & A Grandview, LLC v. 60 Davidson, LLC, NY Slip Op 04743 (2d Dep't July 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 5, 2026

Summary judgment and discovery

A party is entitled to a reasonable opportunity to conduct discovery in advance of a summary judgment determination. The party contending that a summary judgment motion is premature must demonstrate that discovery might lead to relevant evidence or that the facts essential to justify opposition to the motion are exclusively within the knowledge and control of the movant. The mere hope or speculation that evidence sufficient to defeat the motion may be uncovered during the discovery process is insufficient to deny the motion.

Ceesay v. Gotham Bronx, LLC, NY Slip Op 04739 (2d Dep't July 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 4, 2026

Releases of claims

A valid release constitutes a complete bar to an action on a claim which is the subject of the release. A  general release may encompass unknown claims if the parties so intend and the agreement is fairly and knowingly made. Although a defendant has the initial burden of establishing that it has been released from any claims, a signed release shifts the burden to the plaintiff to show that there has been fraud, duress, or some other fact which will be sufficient to void the release.

Brighton Beach 2012, LLC v.  TD Bank, N.A., NY Slip Op 04738 (2d Dep't July 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 3, 2026

Defaults

On a motion for leave to enter a default judgment against a defendant based on the failure to answer or appear, a plaintiff must submit proof of service of the summons and complaint, proof of the facts constituting the cause of action, and proof of the defendant's default. In order to defeat a facially sufficient CPLR 3215 motion, a defendant must show either that there was no default, or that there is a reasonable excuse for the delay and a potentially meritorious defense.

Board of Mgrs. of Rosedale Townhouse Condominium v. Batson, NY Slip Op 04736 (2d Dep't July 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 2, 2026

Products liability

A party injured as a result of a defective product may seek damages against the product manufacturer or others in the chain of distribution if the defect was a substantial factor in causing the injury. A product may be defective when it contains a manufacturing flaw, is defectively designed, or is not accompanied by adequate warnings for the use of the product. A products liability case can be proven without evidence of any particular defect by presenting circumstantial evidence excluding all causes of the accident not attributable to the defendant's product, thereby giving rise to an inference that the accident could only have occurred due to some defect in the product.

A defendant moving for summary judgment dismissing a design defect cause of action must establish, prima facie, that the subject product was reasonably safe for its intended use or that the plaintiff's actions constituted the sole proximate cause of the injuries.

C.B. v. Neal, NY Slip Op 04734 (2d Dep't July 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

August 1, 2026

A driver's negligence

A defendant moving for summary judgment in a negligence action has the burden of establishing, prima facie, a lack of fault in the happening of the accident. A driver is negligent if he makes an unsafe lane change, or fails to see something which, through the proper use of the driver's senses, should have been seen. A violation of the Vehicle and Traffic Law constitutes negligence as a matter of law.

Atali v. Cole, NY Slip Op 04733 (2d Dep't July 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

July 31, 2026

Suing the City

A notice of claim is a condition precedent to an action or special proceeding sounding in tort against a public corporation, pursuant to General Municipal Law §§ 50-e[1][a]; 50-i[1]. Service of a notice of claim upon the City based upon damage to real property must be served within 90 days of the action's arising.  If the plaintiff fails to serve the proper parties with a written notice of claim within the statutory period, the action must be dismissed.

17 Belvedere, LLC v. City of New York, NY Slip Op 04731 (2d Dep't July 29, 2026)

Here is the decision.

July 30, 2026

Relation-back

For claims against one defendant to relate back to claims asserted against another, a plaintiff must demonstrate: (1) that both claims arose out of the same conduct, transaction, or occurrence; (2) that the new party is united in interest with the original defendant such that it may be charged with such notice of the institution of the action that it will not be prejudiced in maintaining its defense on the merits; and (3) that the new party knew or should have known that, but for the plaintiff's mistake as to the identity of the proper parties, the action would have been brought against the new defendant as well. The linchpin of the relation-back doctrine is whether the new defendant had notice within the applicable limitations period.

Louis v. Sood, NY Slip Op 04494 (2d Dep't July 22, 2026)

Here is the decision.

July 29, 2026

Contract law

Freedom of contract prevails in an arm's length transaction between sophisticated parties such that courts generally may not relieve them of the consequences of their bargain. This right is not without limitation. Aside from the defenses relating to the circumstances surrounding the formation of a contract, a party may seek to avoid the consequences of an otherwise valid contract on the ground that it is void against public policy. Courts may void an agreement only upon balancing the public interests favoring invalidation of a term chosen by the parties against those served by enforcement of the clause and concluding that the interests favoring invalidation are stronger. Only a limited group of public policy interests has been identified as sufficiently fundamental to outweigh the freedom of contract, and courts regularly uphold agreements waiving statutory or constitutional rights.

Hochhauser v. Urban Off. Architecture, PLLC, NY Slip Op 04491 (2d Dep't July 22, 2026)

Here is the decision.

July 28, 2026

Jurisdiction

A court may assert general all-purpose jurisdiction or specific conduct-linked jurisdiction over a particular defendant. The court is authorized to exercise general jurisdiction over a foreign corporation when the corporation's affiliations with the state are so continuous and systematic as to render them essentially at home in the forum State. As to specific jurisdiction, New York's long-arm statute, CPLR 302, provides that New York courts may exercise personal jurisdiction over any non-domiciliary who transacts any business within the state or contracts anywhere to supply goods or services in the state. In order to determine whether personal jurisdiction exists under CPLR 302(a)(1), the court must determine (1) whether the defendant purposefully availed itself of the privilege of conducting activities within the forum State by either transacting business in New York or contracting to supply goods or services in New York, and (2) whether the claim arose from that business transaction or from the contract to supply goods or services. In order to satisfy the second prong of the jurisdictional inquiry, there must be an articulable nexus or a substantial relationship between a defendant's New York activities and the cause of action sued upon.

Beltran Tech., Inc. v. Citibank, N.A., NY Slip Op 04487 (2d Dep't July 22, 2026)

Here is the decision.

July 27, 2026

Service of process

Where service is effected pursuant to CPLR 308(4), the affix and mail method, the plaintiff must demonstrate that the summons was affixed to the door of the dwelling place or usual place of abode of the person to be served and mailed to such person's last known residence. At a hearing on the validity of service of process, the plaintiff bears the burden of proving personal jurisdiction by a preponderance of the evidence. In reviewing a determination made after a hearing, the Appellate Division's authority is as broad as that of the hearing court, and it may render the determination it finds warranted by the facts, taking into account that, in a close case, the hearing court had the advantage of seeing and hearing the witnesses.

Bank of Am., N.A. v. D'Andrade, NY Slip Op 04484 (2d Dep't July 22, 2026)

Here is the decision.

July 26, 2026

Employment law

The doctrine of respondeat superior renders the employer vicariously liable for a tort committed by its employee within the scope of employment. An action may be considered to be within the scope of employment when the employee is engaged generally in the business of the employer, or if the act may be reasonably said to be necessary or incidental to the employment. However, as a general rule, an employer who hires an independent contractor, as distinguished from an employee, is not liable for the negligent acts of the independent contractor. Whether an actor is an independent contractor or an employee for the purposes of tort liability is usually a factual issue for the jury.

Bandele v. Rasier-NY, LCC, NY Slip Op 04483 (2d Dep't July 22, 2026)

Here is the decision.