Subject matter jurisdiction is a question of judicial power and, as such, it cannot be dispensed with by litigants because litigants cannot expand a court's power by consent or agreement. Thus, an arbitration clause in an agreement cannot deprive the court of its judicial power. Moreover, under CPLR 7503(a), an order granting a motion to compel arbitration operates to stay a pending or subsequent action, and so the court retains jurisdiction. Thus, the court could not have dismissed the action pursuant to CPLR 3211(a)(2) for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.
1 Holland Villa, LLC vs. Class One Constr. Ltd., NY Slip Op 06880 (1st Dep't November 19, 2026)