The movant must raise new facts that would have changed the outcome of the prior motions, and provide a reasonable excuse for failing to present those facts at the proper time, pursuant to CPLR 2221[e]. Renewal is not a second chance for parties who have failed to exercise due diligence in making their original factual presentation, and it is granted sparingly.
Wade v. Giacobbe, NY Slip Op 07852 (1st Dep't October 31,2019)
Here is the decision.
