Practice point: The fact that the dog was confined to the garage is not a predicate for liability, absent evidence that the confinement was because the owner feared that the dog would harm a visitor.
Students should note that New York does not recognize a common-law cause of action sounding in negligence to recover damages for injuries caused by a domestic animal.
The case is Roche v. Bryant, NY Slip Op 01011 (2d Dept. 2011 ).
Tomorrow's issue is motion practice.